PlentyMoreFish Review

In a Nutshell

Having operated as a paid dating website since 2006, PlentyMoreFish is one of the better-established names in the UK digital dating scene. Users on a budget will be pleased to know that this service offers free subscriptions, though unpaid accounts are restricted in some respects. Uniquely, PlentyMoreFish allows daters to join 7 specific dating ‘ponds’, allowing them to meet potential partners with similar expectations. 

Visit PlentyMoreFish


  • Dating Diary lets you keep track of your love life
  • Ponds ensure you only meet those looking for similar connections
  • Search for partners by interest, age or area


  • Free users can’t tell who has seen their profile
  • No mobile application
Best for‘No strings’ naughty dating
User baseSingles, naughty daters, single parents, christians and divorcees
Number of members2 million
Recommended ageOver 40
Favourite featuresDating Diary, Winks, Who’s Viewed Me

Plenty More Fish Love Stories

Tom: “I signed up on Plenty More Fish…  the messages I received were from very, very desirable women.”

Anonymous: “I met someone through it 3 months ago and that’s going great”

Signup Process

Opening an account is straightforward. Initially, you have to choose a dating pond to join. Don’t worry, this is the only fish joke you’ll have to deal with! There are a total of 7 ponds. The 3 largest are the Single Pond, which is for regular dating, the Silver Pond for daters over 40 and, finally, the Naughty Pond. As you can imagine, the Naughty Pond is for dating without any strings attached. If you’re looking for a slightly more niche selection of potential dates, you might also consider the Single Parent, Christian, Cuddly or Divorced ponds.

After selecting a pond, you’ll be asked whether you’re a ‘Man looking for a woman’ or a ‘Woman looking for a man’ and to enter your email address, name and age. Disappointingly, Plenty More Fish doesn’t offer coverage for users looking for LGBT+ dates. Things get a bit more detailed in the next step where you can upload a photo and answer questions to help your profile stand out with personalised information such as your income and religion. 

Matchmaking & Search Functions

Plenty More Fish’s ponds help you to avoid wasting your time with people looking for different dating experiences. Whenever you log in, you’ll only be matched with profiles of users in the same pond. It’s possible to search for partners by location or age and to narrow the results down by filtering for a range of different attributes.

Profile lists can be sorted by most recent login date, and you can even choose to see users online right now. This is a great way to ensure you only contact people who will actually see your messages.

Also, try out the Encounters tool for a different way to stumble upon admirers. This feature presents you with a stream of user profile photos. If you like one of them, and they like yours too, the pair of you will be automatically notified. 

Features & Communication Tools

When you find a user you’d like to get to know better, you can send them a wink, a message or a live chat request. Winking is a great option if you don’t want to waste time composing the perfect message. In the past, receiving messages was a premium only feature but, happily, this restriction has been lifted. 

PlentyMoreFish lets you spice up your profile with its Dating Diaries feature. With it, you can post blog-style updates, giving potential partners a better insight into your personality. Another stand out feature is the ‘Who’s Viewed Me’ page. Here, you can see anyone who’s looked at your profile and, if you want to, get in touch with them. This is a great time-saving addition because you’ll only be contacting users you know are interested in you.

Who’s Viewed Me is also a great way to tell if your current profile set up is working for you. If you make a change and suddenly people stop checking you out, you’ll know to undo it. 

Safety & Security

PlentyMoreFish offers an extensive set of security recommendations and safety tips to check out before you message or meet other users. The platform is also protected by Online Dating Protector, a service which scans accounts to check they are genuine. All photos and text added to PlentyMoreFish profiles are also subject to review. That’s great if you want to avoid time-wasting bots and inappropriate content.

It is disappointing, however, that PlentyMoreFish doesn’t encrypt the user data stored on its servers. You should bear this fact in mind before uploading any private information to the site.


Premium Plenty More Fish subscriptions start at £12.50 per month. Without one, you can’t chat with partners, post diary updates or see who’s peeked at your profile.

SubscriptionTotal CostCost per monthSavings
1 Month£19.99£19.99---
3 Months£59.95£19.9933%
6 Months£89.95£15.0050%
12 Months£149.95£12.5058%

Help & Support 

In case you run into difficulties, PlentyMoreFish offers a comprehensive support section. There, you can find advice on navigating the website and creating the most attractive possible profile. You can also start a live chat session with support staff who work for PlentyMoreFish’s parent company, Venntro. Sadly, live technical assistance isn’t available 24/7. 

Find Love on PlentyMoreFish

Not every user will find their perfect partner on PlentyMoreFish, But, overall, this is an excellent dating platform. It stands out thanks to its Dating Diary feature which allows you to share who you really are with potential significant others. This is a good option to consider for budget daters thanks to the fairly relaxed restrictions placed on free accounts.

Visit PlentyMoreFish

Advertising Disclosure

This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Please be advised that the operator of this site accepts advertising compensation from companies that appear on the site, and such compensation impacts the location and order in which the companies (and/or their products) are presented, and in some cases may also impact the rating that is assigned to them. To the extent that ratings appear on this site, such rating is determined by our subjective opinion and based on a methodology that aggregates our analysis of brand market share and reputation, each brand's conversion rates, compensation paid to us and general consumer interest. Company listings on this page DO NOT imply endorsement. Except as expressly set forth in our Terms of Use, all representations and warranties regarding the information presented on this page are disclaimed. The information, including pricing, which appears on this site is subject to change at any time.

Top 5 Online Dating Sites